0 items in Cart
Main Street Deli Logo
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Deli Trays
  • Hours of Operations
  • Contact Us
  • Now Hiring
  • Menus
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Deli Trays
  • Hours of Operations
  • Contact Us
  • Now Hiring
  • Menus
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

Main Street Deli Online Ordering Menu

203 W MAIN ST
WEST JEFFERSON, OH 43162
(614) 879-6000
10:30 AM - 6:30 PM
100% of 234 customers recommended
Start your carryout order.
Check Availability
Menu Icon Legend

SIGNATURE HANDCRAFTED SANDWICHES

Italian Sub 
Sliced ham, pepperoni, salami, hot pepper cheese or provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion, banana peppers, and Italian dressing on a sub bun.
$9.49+
The "Devil's Dip" 
Anyone who's been around West Jeff awhile knows about the "Devil's dip"! Though you may have to sneak back there to fly down the hill, you won't get in any trouble with our version of the devil's dip! Cajun turkey, hot pepper cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, and mayo on rye swirl bread.
$9.49+
Cuban 
It's not your regular "Ham and Cheese" sandwich! This delectable sandwich infuses classic ingredients with a little Latin flare! The Cuban starts with sliced ham, in house roasted pork, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard on Cuban bread. Once the sandwich is assembled, it gets toasted under a sandwich press!
$9.49+
"The Rock" (Corned Beef Reuben) 
Corned beef Reuben. One of the best coaches in West Jeff history, jack "The rock" McDowell deserves a sandwich named after him! This is a classic Reuben sandwich. Thin sliced corned beef, sauerkraut, guggisburg baby Swiss, and thousand island dressing on toasted rye swirl bread.
$9.95+
The "Roughrider" (Pastrami Reuben) 
Pastrami Reuben. It wouldn't be right if we didn't name a sandwich after west jeff's mascot, "The roughrider"! Thin sliced pastrami, sauerkraut, guggisburg baby Swiss, and thousand island dressing on toasted rye swirl bread.
$9.95+
The "Ox" Roast Beef 
Named after West Jeff's famous "Ox roast festival", we kicked up your regular roast beef sandwich a notch! Here you'll get roast beef, horseradish cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickles, red onion, and horseradish mayo on sourdough bread.
$9.95+
The "Sarge" (Dagwood) 
Dagwood. Giving a nod to West Jeff Police Sergeant, Rob Campbell, we named our version of the "Dagwood" after him knowing he has a big appetite! This sandwich has turkey, roast beef, ham, American cheese, mayo, on sourdough bread. It will weigh in at almost 1.5lbs!!
$10.49+
Main Street Fried Bologna Sandwich 
Hey, it's an Ohio thing and we're proud of it! Try our version of the classic midwestern sandwich. We took a classic and made it just a little bit better by adding green onion cheese, grilled red onions, mustard, and of course falter's thick-cut old fashioned bologna on a roll. Trust me, you'll be hooked!
$7.95+
The "Turkey Trot" 
Sliced turkey, baby Swiss, lettuce, and cranberry mayo on sourdough bread.
$8.49+
Classic Ham Sandwich 
Black forest ham, Havarti cheese, lettuce, tomato, oil and vinegar, salt and pepper, and mayo on sourdough bread.
$8.49+
Tuna Salad Sandwich 
$8.49+
Chicken Salad Sandwich 
$8.49+
Ham Salad Sandwich 
$8.49+
Chicken Caesar Wrap 
Seasoned grilled chicken breast, lettuce, and Parmesan cheese with Caesar dressing in a tortilla shell.
$8.49+
Gourmet Grilled Cheese (soup not included) 
Pick 2 slices of your favorite cheese on thick-cut Texas toast.
$5.95+
Turkey Wrap 
Pan-roasted turkey, lettuce, shaved Parmesan cheese, and mayo in a tortilla shell.
$8.49+
Buffalo Chicken Wrap 
Buffalo chicken, shredded mozzarella, lettuce, and buffalo sandwich sauce in a tortilla wrap. Spicy.
$8.49+
Inferno 
A nod to Jefferson Township Fire Department for helping come up with this one. It starts with seasoned chicken breast strips, Buffalo sandwich sauce, a provolone and mozzarella shredded cheese blend heated up, then toasted on a sub bun with lettuce and tomato. Make it "Backdraft" style with scorpion or Carolina reaper cheddar for an extra charge. Spicy.
$10.49+
Turkey Club 
Pan-roasted turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo layered between 3 pieces of toasted white bread.
$8.95+
BLT 
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on toasted white bread.
$6.95+
Main Street Pulled Pork 
In house-roasted pork that we pull by hand. This sandwich is paired with walnut creek's apple butter BBQ sauce on a gourmet bun.
$6.50+
Meatball Sub | Fridays & Saturdays Only 
$9.95
The New Yorker 
Hot pastrami, brown mustard on toasted sourdough bread.
$9.95+
Cheese Quesadilla's 
1- 1O inch tortilla cut in thirds. Our quesadilla’s are made with a Monterey Jack cheese blend served with salsa, sour cream, or both. You can also add chicken, bacon, or spicy cheeses below.
$6.95+
Veggie Sub 
Lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers, and pickles in a bun with mayo or Italian dressing.
$7.95+
Veggie Wrap 
Lettuce, tomato, onion, banana peppers, and pickles in a tortilla wrap with mayo or Italian dressing.
$7.95+
Kid's Turkey Sub 
With your choice of cheese on an 8" sub bun.
$6.00+
Kid's Ham Sub 
With your choice of cheese on an 8" sub bun.
$6.00+
Classic Turkey Sandwich 
$8.49+
Main Street Deli Cooler Sub | White American 
$6.99
Main Street Deli Cooler Sub | Hot Pepper 
$6.99

DRINKS

Coke 
$2.59
Coke de Mexico (Glass Bottle) 
$2.59
Cherry Coke 
$2.59
Coke Vanilla 
$2.59
Coke Zero 
$2.59
Diet Coke 
$2.59
Barq's Rootbeer 
$2.59
Fanta Orange Soda 
$2.59
Pink Lemonade 
$2.59
Barq's Red Cream Soda 
$2.59
Sprite 
$2.59
Turkey Hill Diet Tea 
$1.99
Turkey Hill Green Tea 
$1.99
Turkey Hill Lemonade 
$1.99
Turkey Hill Lemonade (1/2 Gallon) 
$3.49
Turkey Hill Peach Tea 
$1.99
Turkey Hill Pomegranate Lemonade 
$1.99
Turkey Hill Raspberry Ice Tea 
$1.99
Turkey Hill Straw Kiwi 
$1.99
Turkey Hill Sweet Iced Tea 
$1.99
Turkey Hill Sweet Tea (1/2 Gallon) 
$3.49
Bottle Water 
$1.00
Sprite de Mexico 
$2.59
Turkey Hill Iced Tea 
$1.99
Blue Powerade 
$2.59
Red Powerade 
$2.59
Mello Yello 
$2.59
Dr. Pepper 
$2.59
Monster Energy - White 
$1.99
1/2 Gallon Lemonade/Tea 
$3.49
Turkey Hill Lemonade Tea 
$1.99
Cherry Vanilla Coke 
$2.59
Kutztown Orange  Soda | Single 
$2.59
Pepsi 
$2.59
Mt. Dew 
$2.59
Diet Pepsi 
$2.59
Diet Dr. Pepper 
$2.59
Gatorade Frost 
$2.59
Diet Mt. Dew 
$2.59
Rockstar Pure Zero 
$2.59
Pepsi Wild Cherry 
$2.59
Gatorade Fruit Punch 
$2.59
Mt. Dew Code Red 
$2.59
Dr. Pepper Cream Soda 
$2.59
Dole Orange Juice 
$1.99
Dole Apple Juice 
$1.99
Gold Peak Unsweet Tea 
$1.99
Starbucks Frappuccino 
$2.99
Starry Soda 
$2.59
Monster | Ultra Watermelon 
$2.99
Rockstar Watermelon 
$2.99
Kutztown Root Beer | Single 
$2.59
Mt. Dew Voltage 
$2.59
Starbucks Caramel Macchiato 
$2.99
Gatorade Cool Blue 
$2.59
Celcius Orange 
$2.99
Monster - Ultra Strawberry Dreams 
$1.99

SIDE DELI SALADS

Side Italian Pasta Salad 
Chilled salad with a pasta base.
$1.99
Side Potato Salad 
Cold dish made from seasoned potatoes.
$1.99
Side Coleslaw 
$1.99
Side Macaroni Salad 
Cold pasta salad made with macaroni noodles.
$1.99
Side Cottage Cheese 
Soft white cheese made from soured milk curds.
$1.99
Side Maple Bacon Potato Salad 
Cold dish made from seasoned bacon potatoes.
$2.49
Side Tomato Bacon Pasta 
$1.99
Side Cucumber Salad 
$1.79
Side Rotini Parmesan Salad 
$2.49

PICKLES

Jumbo Kosher Dill 
$1.50
Beet Pickled Egg 
$0.75
Mustard Egg 
$0.75

SIDE DESSERTS

Reese's Stuffed Brownie 
$4.99
Strawberry Cheesecake Delight 
$2.49
Cookies n' Cream Mousse 
$2.49
Peanut Butter Mousse 
$2.49
Cheesecake Cone 
$3.49
Cheesecake Cookie 
$3.49
Side Banana Pudding 
$2.49
Side Chocolate Mousse 
$2.49
Cherry Delight Mousse 
$2.49

CHIPS

Grippo's BBQ Chips 
$0.99
Dorito Chips 
$0.99
Lay's Classic 
$0.99
Walnut Creek BBQ 
Large Bag
$4.99
Walnut Creek Kettle Chips 
Large Bag
$4.99
Walnut Creek Queso Chips 
Large Bag
$4.99
Walnut Creek Cheese Puffs 
$2.49
Pork Rinds Regular 
$2.59
Pork Rinds - Hot 
$2.59
Pork Rinds - BBQ 
$2.59
Walnut Creek Sour Cream & Onion 
Large Bag
$4.99
Baked Lays Cheddar & Sour Cream 
$0.99
Baked Lays Sour Cream & Onion 
$0.99
Baked Lays Regular 
$0.99
Baked Lays BBQ 
$0.99
Baked Cheetos 
$0.99
Diablo Pretzels 
Made with Carolina Reaper & Scorpion Pepper dust on a ranch pretzel. Delicious!
$7.00
Round Tortilla Chips 
$2.99
Great Lakes BBQ Chip 
Large Bag
$4.99
Great Lakes Wavy Chip 
Large Bag
$4.99
Great Lakes Buffalo Chip 
Large Bag
$4.99
Great Lakes Original Chip 
Large Bag
$4.99
Great Lakes Salt & Vinegar Chip 
Large Bag
$4.99
Great Lakes Parmesan Ranch 
Large Bag
$4.99
WC Cheddar Puff 
Large Bag
$2.49
WC Butter Puff 
Large Bag
$2.49
Great Lakes Cherry BBQ Chips 
$4.99

Desserts

Gummy Bears 
$2.99
Strawberry Twists 
$2.99
Cinnamon Rolls | Vanilla Frosting 
$6.99
Pumpkin Creme Roll 
$6.99
Red Velvet Creme Roll 
$6.99
Cinnamon Rolls | Maple Icing 
$6.99
Marsha's Buckeyes 
$5.99
Peanut Butter Mousse 
$2.49
Reese's Stuffed Brownie 
$4.99
Cheesecake Cone 
$3.49
Cheesecake Cookie 
$3.49
Strawberry Cheesecake Delight 
$2.49
Whoopie Pie Brownie 
$4.99
Yoder's Molasses Cookies 
$5.99
Your cart is empty.
  • Visit our Facebook Visit our Instagram Visit our Yelp Visit our TripAdvisor
Powered by Menufy © 2023
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.